A London court has ruled against Mitch Winehouse, the father of late singer Amy Winehouse, in his legal dispute with two of her close friends over the auction of her personal clothing.
The case, dismissed on April 20, centered on claims that Catriona Gourlay and Naomi Parry sold around $1.2 million worth of the “Back to Black” artist’s wardrobe in auctions held in 2021 and 2023 without Mitch’s permission. The two women argued that all 141 items — including the dress Amy wore during her final performance in Serbia — either belonged to them or had been gifted by the singer before her death in 2011 at age 27.
Mitch, who manages his daughter’s estate, insisted they had no right to sell the items and accused them of intentionally hiding the sales.
Judge Sarah Clarke acknowledged Mitch’s deep personal loss and his efforts to preserve Amy’s legacy, but also noted that her estate has made him very wealthy. She said he is highly protective of how Amy’s memory is used, especially when money is involved, and is also concerned with ensuring financial benefit for the family.
The court highlighted that Mitch initially supported the idea of the 2021 auction with proceeds going to the Amy Winehouse Foundation, but later changed his stance, proposing a split where only 30% would go to the charity and 70% to the estate.
Judge Clarke also remarked that Mitch tends to try to control situations and expects others to follow his wishes.
According to court documents, Mitch allegedly offered Parry $250,000 to settle the matter and recover the auction proceeds, but she refused, reportedly saying she would rather destroy the money than give him any.
In dismissing the case, the judge pointed out that Amy was known for her generosity and frequently gave belongings to friends.
Following the decision, Parry shared a video statement expressing relief that the ruling had fully cleared her name after years of what she described as harmful and baseless accusations. She emphasized her close personal and professional relationship with Amy, calling it one built on trust and loyalty, and said the judgment restores the truth about their bond.
